With spring training upon us, the new MLB season is almost here! Is there a better way to get the festivities started than to make a few MLB picks?
Well, not so fast. If you don’t already have a favorite sportsbook, finding one may not be as easy as you think. With the U.S. betting industry growing so rapidly, there are dozens of MLB betting sites that could be worth your time.
Don’t want to spend the next week agonizing over which sportsbook to join? This short guide will help you make your decision much faster!
Choosing an MLB Betting Site
Before settling on a specific sportsbook, you need to know what you’re looking for. Here are some key factors that may influence your decision.
Legality and Licensing
The first thing you should confirm is that the sportsbook you opt for is legal in your state. Many sportsbooks now operate across all regulated states, but each state also has its own set of legalized betting sites.
It’s also best to avoid offshore betting sites. Since they usually fall in a legal gray area, many of them welcome U.S. players. At the same time, they also tend to be less regulated, putting your sensitive information at risk.
Wagers and Odds
Every major sportsbook offers a fairly standard lineup of MLB wagers. That said, some betting sites have more to offer when it comes to the more exotic types of wagers. These include:
- Player and game props
- Alternate lines
- Special bets
You should also take a close look at the MLB betting percentages on offer. These odds tend to be similar across sportsbooks, but even small differences can influence your potential payout.
Take a specific MLB game and sift through the sportsbooks to see which one offers the best odds. No sportsbook will offer the best odds every time, but repeating this process should help you notice some patterns.
User Experience
The look and feel of a betting platform plays a bigger role in sports betting than you may think. If you think you’ll spend a lot of time on a betting app or site, you should be comfortable using them. Some things to consider are:
- Platform design
- Page load speed
- Ease of navigation
- Live betting features
Looking into these factors is particularly important if you’re planning to use a mobile app. Don’t forget to confirm that your sportsbook has an app that’s compatible with your phone!
Welcome Bonuses
Most sportsbooks use welcome bonuses and promotions to attract new customers. Though all these offers will help you boost your initial bankroll, some are more valuable than others.
For example, you’ll often see offers for a bonus bet if your first bet with a sportsbook loses. Some sportsbooks put a limit on how much you can wager on them, such as up to $200. The small print may also note:
- Special odds requirements
- How much time you have to place bets
- How long you have to use bonus bets
Finally, consider that the intro promo is only a small part of a sportsbook’s range of promotions. Before choosing one, see if they offer deals specific to MLB betting, whether they feature odds boosts, and so on.
Banking Options
When you win a wager, you want your deposit to go through instantly. Unfortunately, sportsbooks vary wildly when it comes to withdrawal speeds. This often depends on which withdrawal options they support, such as:
- Play+ cards
- Online bank transfer
- ACH/eCheck
- PayPal
Best MLB Betting Sites in 2025
Now that you know what features you’re looking for, let’s go over how the major U.S. sportsbooks can suit your needs. Here’s why each of these three popular sportsbooks can be a great fit for MLB betting!
FanDuel
FanDuel is the best sportsbook on the market due to its all-around game. For starters, they usually charge the smallest vig for MLB games. Their edge in this regard is particularly noticeable with run-line bets.
The market variety on offer is also excellent. They offer all season-long bets you can think of, such as:
- Win totals for all teams
- Player awards like MVP and Cy Young
- Pitcher strikeout props
The FanDuel user experience is second to none. The app is responsive, easy to navigate, and almost never crashes. It also supports biometric logins, which can be essential for locking in bets quickly.
Their sign-up promos are solid, particularly the classic “Bet $5, get $200” one. What this means is that if your first bet wins, FanDuel will give you $200 in bonus bets. That said, you only get 14 days to use your bonus.
BetMGM
The main thing that sets BetMGM apart is their commitment to innovation. They offer a variety of tools that can be handy for MLB bettors.
For instance, their Edit My Bet feature allows you to tweak your parlays instantly. If you have, say, Ohtani on one of your legs and hear he’s been struggling in practice, you can swap him out or reduce your stake.
The Auto Cash Out tool is another useful feature for experienced bettors. It allows you to set a particular profit or loss threshold. Once your bet or parlay hits that number, the system will automatically cash you out.
BetRivers
If you’re interested in betting on MLB after the first pitch, BetRivers has got you covered. Their menu of in-game MLB bets is top-notch, from the standard options to inning-specific results.
This versatility extends to their micro-betting offerings as well. You can place wagers on things like how an at-bat will end or what will happen with the next hit. They also have a solid selection of future bets.
Finally, BetRivers stands out for its fast payouts. In most cases, you’ll be able to collect your winnings in less than 24 hours.
Get Free Baseball Picks Today!
Hopefully, this guide has helped you figure out what separates MLB betting sites from one another. The next step: choosing one of these sites and starting your MLB betting journey!
At Ultimate Capper, we can help you with this part! We offer a wide variety of free sports picks for all types of MLB bets. Our MLB experts have years of experience in this industry and have no issues sharing this knowledge with you.
Want to get started? Sign up for our newsletter for free MLB picks every morning!
